type
Post
Created date
Jun 15, 2022 06:01 AM
category
Meta-Learning
tags
Reading
Academic Paper
Communication
Research
status
Published
Language
English
From
Apply knowledge
summary
The following are the posts related to the techniques when reading academic materials. This repo serves as an introduction and instructions on how to read academic papers by understanding the structure of it, and offered some advices in particular to academic paper and generally.
slug
password
Author
Jason Ching Yuen Siu
Priority
Featured
Featured
Origin
Type
URL
Youtube
Youtube
icon
The following are the posts related to the techniques when reading academic materials. This repo serves as an introduction and instructions on how to read academic papers by understanding the structure of it, and offered some advices in particular to academic paper and generally.
On difficult texts
Steps on reading academic paper
How to Read for Grad School - By Miriam
Insights
Read Strategically, Not Linearly.
Be purposeful by asking:
- What is the author trying to say?
- What is motivating her exploration of this topic?
- What does this research contribute?
- What academic conversations is the author trying to align with?
- What are the main arguments of this piece?
- What are their assumption?
- How does this relate to my other assigned readings?”
Read critically
Steps to read (Here)
- Start with the title. This should give you an idea what you're going to read about and help you decide if the paper will cover what you need to know.
- Read the abstract. This is a summary of the paper a should tell you the hypothesis, scope of investigation, and conclusions. If you don't have time for anything else, you want to abstract.
- Look at the authors and date. Consider where they're from, what kind of collaboration and facilities were involved, and the age of the paper. It may be outdated or superceded by more in-depth work with better equipment or techniques, so don't assume this paper is the final word on the subject.
- Read the conclusions. This should better explain the limitations and nuances of the work than the abstract.
- Read the introduction. This should explain the reasons the authors undertook the investigation, and detail the conditions of the work, sample sizes, test vs control groups, etc.
- Finally, if you're not satisfied yet, read the body of the paper. This is where the authors spell out the methodology, discuss data sets, perform analyses, and otherwise get into the 'meat' of the work performed.
Structure of an academic paper [Post]
Read in this order
Abstract :
- the main question of the paper
- What are the process of investment?
- what the paper does
- Why the paper
- what results they get, the authors get
- Bare in mind it is just a idea, that cannot really buy
Introduction (What, Why)
- Introduce the domain, and who the readers
- The importance of investment in few words
- The perplexity of finding stocks to invest
- The importance of this project
RQ
What is the overall research question the paper seeks to answer?
Why is it important that we have evidence about the question?
What are the specific hypotheses?
Are the hypotheses drawn or inferred correctly from the underlying theory?
Conclusion
Related work
- To know the overview in this area >> so that you know how to amplify your contribution when writing a paper.
Can write according to
Here mentioned how to write a section of related work.
Findings
Do the authors’ inferences actually follow from the tests?
Do the authors overreach in the interpretation (Over-interpret)? Underreach?
Methodology
Where does the datasets come from?
Do the tests in the paper actually test the hypotheses of interest?
Are the data well suited for the tests? Are the proxies reasonable?
Are the econometric methods appropriate given the data and the tests?
The process of visualising, how is it presented?(What, How)
Discussion
The process of visualising, why is it presented?(Why)
Insight about :
- Use of finding
- Who will benefit
- Who can give more advice or do more related work
What could have been done better? Is it worth doing better?
What are the remaining questions?
Are there any clever methods or approaches that could be applied to another study?
Are there any interesting by-product results that could be extended?
Advice on before and after reading
Opinion 4 - Questions to ask when reading papers (Similar to here) *More important* (Here)
1. Research Questions
a. What is the overall research question the paper seeks to answer?
b. Why is it important that we have evidence about the question?
c. What are the specific hypotheses?
d. Are the hypotheses drawn or inferred correctly from the underlying theory?
2. Research Design
a. Do the tests in the paper actually test the hypotheses of interest?
b. Are the data well suited for the tests? Are the proxies reasonable?
c. Are the econometric methods appropriate given the data and the tests?
3. Research Interpretation
a. Do the authors’ inferences actually follow from the tests?
b. Do the authors overreach in the interpretation? Underreach?
4. Next Steps
a. What could have been done better? Is it worth doing better?
b. What are the remaining questions?
c. Are there any clever methods or approaches that could be applied to another study?
d. Are there any interesting by-product results that could be extended?
Opinion 2 (Here)
Get your requirement. You could start from the end and work backwards. Specifically, what are the requirements of your assignment? Outline the headings of the final paper you imagine having to turn in. For example: introduction; brief summary of article; stuff the author did well, things you question, have concerns about, etc,; summary of your thoughts/recommendations (if applicable). So, once you've matched your "planned output" to the structure/assessment criteria supplied by your instructor, you're ready to read!
Given the headings I outlined in my example, you'll want to read with questions that would help you write each section (under each of those headings and their subsequent sub-headings). For example, what is being studied, who has sponsored it, who has written it and whit which institutions/orgs are they affiliated? What is their stated purpose, research questions, etc? What have they said in their lit review? Does it seem thorough? Can you understand why they'd have done their study the way they did based on how they wrote about the literature? What are their methods? Are they reasonable given the lit review, field, etc? Are the conclusions they've reasonable given what they said they did and how they managed the data? Do those data mgmt techniques make sense, etc.
I could go on. You get the picture.
Jot notes under each of your headings. So, read with those things in mind. Jot notes under each of your headings. Gradually sentences emerge and you begin to see your ideas come together bit by bit. You may find your headings don't work. Change them. Do what you need to do with the structure (within the constraints of the assignment) to communicate your thoughts.
It's not meant to be your magnum opus so don't worry about how everything sounds at first. Just type simple sentences. Bullet points, even. Just peck away. Then go do something else then come back and read your big messy document of headings with lists, sentences, words, maybe quotes from the article, etc. You'll have something good. Use it, keep building. Check your progress against the assignment criteria. Keep writing/reading. Go do something else. Edit your brilliance. Rinse repeat. Edit. Submit.
I realize your question was about reading but it also seemed to be a question about (your) writing, too. Good luck! PM if you have any questions.
Opinion 3 - Do and Don’t *More important* (Here)
![notion image](https://www.notion.so/image/https%3A%2F%2Ffile.notion.so%2Ff%2Ff%2Fe1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%2Fe2f8cd3a-c3eb-4774-a97f-d20464f7f475%2FUntitled.png%3Ftable%3Dblock%26id%3Dd003444b-e43a-4395-a00b-8ca522c20048%26spaceId%3De1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%26expirationTimestamp%3D1725789600000%26signature%3DFScqWqOpLKIiFJxtareqJLabE4qBnvrbUwyMUS1DXcM?table=block&id=d003444b-e43a-4395-a00b-8ca522c20048&cache=v2)
![notion image](https://www.notion.so/image/https%3A%2F%2Ffile.notion.so%2Ff%2Ff%2Fe1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%2F298e64f5-9c68-43c3-8856-986dc7d46cbd%2FUntitled.png%3Ftable%3Dblock%26id%3Ddcdbb4f7-a285-45c0-b840-418ad7099d32%26spaceId%3De1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%26expirationTimestamp%3D1725789600000%26signature%3D4MzNDxMrucv2KeAWE0lw3Dc38rFV3PysVWSuqECY820?table=block&id=dcdbb4f7-a285-45c0-b840-418ad7099d32&cache=v2)
![notion image](https://www.notion.so/image/https%3A%2F%2Ffile.notion.so%2Ff%2Ff%2Fe1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%2F45c391ca-6c32-4e50-b3a0-e7c6a99cbcc2%2FUntitled.png%3Ftable%3Dblock%26id%3D9b2fc4c9-835d-435b-9e65-e857bd73fc92%26spaceId%3De1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%26expirationTimestamp%3D1725789600000%26signature%3DdvvGz8J9gpLIt-8SnlsXI8-3IJdfYcuA4YUGes8ttDI?table=block&id=9b2fc4c9-835d-435b-9e65-e857bd73fc92&cache=v2)
General tips on any kinds of texts
Highlight system
![notion image](https://www.notion.so/image/https%3A%2F%2Ffile.notion.so%2Ff%2Ff%2Fe1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%2Fe75fbad4-7779-4b7b-a39a-ce5a4cbce8e2%2F5104B744-252F-40B3-B846-C797E15DA6CF.png%3Ftable%3Dblock%26id%3Daa398e3c-2a00-4ce4-822e-9ebf1262cb79%26spaceId%3De1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%26expirationTimestamp%3D1725789600000%26signature%3D8UgpjF-eubtZ3UFNd28gXyK2rdunwz7-Bm102c_23VI?table=block&id=aa398e3c-2a00-4ce4-822e-9ebf1262cb79&cache=v2)
Star in the margin = key takeaway when I read those sentences, I know the key points
Q = quote
![notion image](https://www.notion.so/image/https%3A%2F%2Ffile.notion.so%2Ff%2Ff%2Fe1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%2Feacff3ca-75e6-4933-aa26-dca3dbeb808d%2F372B4DA2-8D11-480E-BFE3-6168B114BE46.jpeg%3Ftable%3Dblock%26id%3D49422b54-ab34-47eb-9c21-c4a40afe554b%26spaceId%3De1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%26expirationTimestamp%3D1725789600000%26signature%3Dc7jE7rxfjaAAjaK_ZUzhnzKUWktS9jqlFRbA32RcYyg?table=block&id=49422b54-ab34-47eb-9c21-c4a40afe554b&cache=v2)
- Example :
3 rules in communication and understanding [Post]
- Always rmb to communicate your messages wrapped in 3 things.
- e.g. Try to ask everyone to come up only 3 questions or items for the meeting.
- If you don't understand an idea, try to read the explanation for 3 times.
- Try to paraphrase / use 3 ways to explain an idea.
4 Steps to Read Difficult Texts Faster [Post]
- Group easy words and sprint to the hard parts.
- Sub-vocalise and slow down on big words or complex ideas.
- Take a small pause to visualise or connect what you've just learned with the big picture.
- Think about where you think the text is going to lead you
Similar to this picture [Post]
From words to your clause, from clause to statement
![notion image](https://www.notion.so/image/https%3A%2F%2Ffile.notion.so%2Ff%2Ff%2Fe1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%2Fed1bfd66-adf6-44a9-984e-67878418a1de%2F57567D3E-983B-4B18-BFB4-EDE60232F1DC.jpeg%3Ftable%3Dblock%26id%3D9d4cab53-c643-4a94-be28-c1ff12e80519%26spaceId%3De1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%26expirationTimestamp%3D1725789600000%26signature%3DiDAnPGxheQjuWew3cQj6to7APNPUroODOmD7hWD33qY?table=block&id=9d4cab53-c643-4a94-be28-c1ff12e80519&cache=v2)
![notion image](https://www.notion.so/image/https%3A%2F%2Ffile.notion.so%2Ff%2Ff%2Fe1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%2Faaa53701-16b9-42ef-9ae3-083451bb908f%2FEB78C4F8-8FF9-42AA-9703-29952DCC7795.jpeg%3Ftable%3Dblock%26id%3De8682870-8c58-445f-909d-795ea037cbe0%26spaceId%3De1c5ba0e-562a-49b0-8505-ce5e38fc061b%26expirationTimestamp%3D1725789600000%26signature%3Dw2aOXF6_6Bo12asb-T4QnubGRgT99ppIQTG2tNF5P8E?table=block&id=e8682870-8c58-445f-909d-795ea037cbe0&cache=v2)
Generals tips on writing
- Use an active voice instead of a passive one. e.g. (“John McCarthy designed LISP in 1958)” rather than the indirect one (“LISP was designed by …”)
- Use synonyms in order to deal with repetitions; and avoid weak words or phrases and paragraphs presenting more than one idea.
- Use the present tense over the past or the future.
Relevant links
- Author:Jason Siu
- URL:https://jason-siu.com/article/b33aadbc-71a2-4fa3-82e8-94811acbd035
- Copyright:All articles in this blog, except for special statements, adopt BY-NC-SA agreement. Please indicate the source!
Relate Posts